Meeting Them Where They Are: What Tibetan Buddhism Teaches About Animal Ethics Today

How do we hold Buddhist philosophy and lived reality at the same time—especially when it comes to something as urgent and intimate as what we eat?

Geoff Barstow, a scholar of Tibetan Buddhism and animal ethics, has spent years tracing how Tibetan thinkers have wrestled with this question. His research reveals something surprising: the tradition offers not rigid rules but a model of ethical flexibility. Tibetan Buddhist teachers have long recognized that moral progress doesn’t require perfection. It asks instead that we meet ourselves and others with honesty, and move as gently as we can.

In a moment when discussions of animal welfare and climate can feel polarized—when the boundaries between right and wrong are sharply drawn—Barstow’s work invites a different kind of conversation. One rooted in complexity. One that makes space for doubt, for partial steps, for the reality that we are all living in conditions that make perfect choices impossible.

We sat down with Geoff to explore what Tibetan perspectives on animal ethics can teach us about sustainability, moral assumptions, and the practice of change.

What first drew you to studying animal ethics at the intersection of Buddhism and Tibetan culture?

The simple truth is that this was an issue I already cared deeply about. I was vegetarian. I had been in conversations with a number of contemporary religious leaders, so this topic was already close to my heart. Interestingly, my original dissertation was on something entirely different—something I didn’t feel particularly connected to. Then one day, I happened to be reading Kunzang Lama’i Shelung and came across an anti-meat passage. It jumped out at me.

I’d always heard that Tibetans traditionally ate a lot of meat, so seeing Patrul Rinpoche, this great 19th-century master, argue so strongly against it was striking. It made me wonder whether other premodern lamas and masters had expressed similar views. Once I started looking, I realized there was a lot more discussion on the topic than I’d expected. That discovery really set the course for my research.

So, it began with personal concern—something I cared about instinctively—and grew into a genuine academic and ethical inquiry. I still feel incredibly fortunate to have been able to study and write on an issue that feels both personally meaningful and socially important.

How does your personal background shape this interest, and why do you see this field as particularly relevant today, especially in relation to sustainability?

I’ll just say straight up, I think this work is deeply relevant because of how animals continue to be treated—both within Tibetan culture and in Western societies. We’re all aware, in one way or another, of the horrors of the industrial animal system and the suffering it produces.

My hope with this research is simply to add to an ongoing conversation. I’m not interested in telling people what they should or shouldn’t do. Instead, I want to provide resources, raise thoughtful questions, and invite people to come to their own conclusions

How would you compare attitudes toward animal ethics in Tibet and in Western societies? From a historical perspective, how have these views developed over time, and where do you see the most striking differences and similarities today?

I think on a theoretical level the differences are quite clear and striking. In the monotheistic traditions of the West, animals have often been explicitly excluded from the domain of care, at least on a theoretical level. In practice, things are more complicated, and in many cases conditions for animals may actually be better. But in the Western monotheistic traditions, there have been a number of influential thinkers who have stated quite directly that the suffering that animals undergo does not really matter.

In the Buddhist context the theory is quite different. It is broadly accepted that animals are sentient beings and therefore what we do to them matters morally speaking. Their experience matters. The catch, of course, is that this has not always translated into consistent practices such as widespread vegetarianism.

So on the theoretical level, the contrast is sharp; on the practical level—what people actually do—the picture is much more complicated in both the Euro-American and the traditional Buddhist worlds. One difference I find especially striking today, and that I often talk about in lectures, is the way these traditions relate to labels. In contemporary Western animal welfare and animal rights movements, there tends to be a strong focus on fixed identities and strict adherence to them. Someone is “a vegan,” for instance, and that is taken to mean a specific set of rules; if they eat honey, then they are told, “You’re not really vegan.” The emphasis is on clear terms with firm boundaries: either you are or you are not.

In the Tibetan tradition, from the premodern period to the present, I see much more emphasis on encouraging people to do the best they can rather than on rigid labels. Tibetan authors will often say things like, “If you cannot be completely vegetarian, that’s all right—eat less meat, avoid it on holy days, or abstain from certain kinds.” You get a whole range of practices that I have described elsewhere as forms of “partial vegetarianism.” I simply do not see as much of this flexible, graded approach in contemporary Euro-American animal welfare discourse.

I think this is one of the most interesting areas of difference, and also a place where Buddhist ethics and Buddhist discussions of these issues could be helpful if brought more fully into Euro-American conversations about animals and sustainability.

What can debate about meat consumption and animal ethics in Tibet teach people in the West about their own everyday choices? In what ways do these Tibetan perspectives challenge or differ from dominant Western approaches to animal ethics?

I’d sum it up in two points—both of which come up frequently in Tibetan discussions of animals and could usefully be brought more fully into Western conversations.

First, there is a basic moral assumption in Tibetan Buddhist ethics: animals matter. This is not typically up for debate. It is taken for granted that animals are sentient beings with moral significance. By contrast, in Euro-American contexts, the moral status of animals is still contested. I know plenty of people who have told me that animals don’t think—they’re not aware or conscious–so they don’t matter. Tibetan perspectives challenge this uncertainty by insisting—quite simply—that animals matter on moral and ethical grounds. Bringing this assumption more fully into Western discussions would add more complexity to these debates.

Second, as I mentioned earlier, the Tibetan approach emphasizes meeting people where they are and gently nudging them to reduce their impact on animal. By contrast, Western approaches to animal ethics can sometimes emphasize strict predefined diets like veganism, vegetarianism, or pescatarianism. A simpler, more flexible approach—one that allows for gradual change rather than strict rules—may be something Western perspectives could learn from Tibetan traditions.

You describe Tibetan Buddhism not as a static or timeless philosophy, but as a dynamic tradition shaped by ongoing negotiations between religious ideals, cultural practices, and environmental realities. Can you elaborate on this view, and explain how it reflects the challenges and conditions of the 21st century?

I think this is, in some ways, an obvious point—something that becomes clear as soon as we stop to think about it—but it is also something we do not always fully recognize. Tibetans were, and are, people living in complex societies. They have culture, religion, and a range of competing needs and interests. Yet discussions of religion and philosophy can sometimes flatten this complexity, losing sight of the richness and beauty of people’s lives. These are deeply textured, culturally intricate societies, where far more is happening than a simple or abstract application of Buddhist philosophy. This may be an obvious truth, but it is one that many—especially non-Tibetans—don’t recognize.

As for how this perspective relates to the challenges and conditions of the 21st century, there are plenty of debates about whether our time is more complex than the past. I’m not sure that’s something we can definitively answer. But it’s clear that we live in a complicated world. One of the great values of studying history is that it allows us to examine the complexity of other times and places—and, in turn, better recognize similar dynamics in our own lives. In that sense, history doesn’t simply help us understand the past; it also helps us make sense of the challenges and conditions of the present.

Geoff Barstow

Geoff Barstow first encountered Tibetan Buddhism in 1999, while on a study abroad trip in college. Since that time, the study of Tibetan religion, history, and culture has been the focus of his professional life. He has spent more than six years conducting research in Nepal, China, and Tibet. That research focuses on the history of vegetarianism on the Tibetan plateau, asking questions about how animals were viewed, how they were treated (ie: eaten), what that can tell us about Tibetan Buddhism, and how Buddhist ideas about animal ethics might impact broader philosophical discussions. As a teacher, his courses emphasize various aspects of Buddhist religious thought, but also seek to explore how those ideas have been lived and experienced by actual Buddhists.

Share the Post:
Scroll to Top